Broken Down & Out
GlobalNewscast
  Not Fair
 
Trial by jury was established in the Constitution. It relies on the integrity of each member of the jury and upon the integrity of the twelve jurors acting as one. Each juror and the jury body must use intellect, judgment, intrinsic integrity, and clear away all preconceived ideas and biases.
< Sonja Chambers, jury foreperson
Former Illinois Governor George Ryan, 72, and his co-defendant were convicted on all charges following a several-month trial. Charges included mail fraud, racketeering, tax fraud, making false statements to investigators, and filing false income tax returns.
These defendants may or may not have been guilty of any or all of the charges. They deserve a fair trial.
Sonja Chambers, foreperson of the jury that convicted former Governor Ryan and his co-defendant on all charges, failed to honestly disclose her personal background. She lied on the sworn jury questionnaire. Chambers has sought orders of protection and been involved in civil legal proceedings.
Foreperson Chambers has a history in civil courts in two Illinois counties and has filed orders of protection. However, she checked "no" on her jury questionnaire regarding her having ever been involved in any lawsuit or court proceeding as a plaintiff, defendant, victim or witness. However, court records show she has appeared in court or had involvement in court proceedings on various occasions.
County court records indicate Chambers sought an order of protection against another man in 1998. Another County's records indicate she filed an order of protection in 2001, against her estranged husband. In December of 2001, police were summoned to her home regarding a domestic violence situation. Chambers claimed her husband had kicked in a door and punched her in the face. According to the police report, officers found no evidence supporting her claims.
Chambers' estranged husband was arrested outside Chambers' home on a warrant in October, 2004, for failing to appear in court, the couple is in the midst of a divorce, and her husband is seeking custody of their child and support for the child and himself. Chambers checked "no" on the questionnaire when asked if she, a spouse or significant other had ever been personally interested in the outcome of a criminal case.
US District Judge Rebecca Pallmeyer was made aware of some of Chambers' past. Ryan's lawyers tried twice to remove her during the trial. Judge Pallmeyer refused. However, failure to disclose prior court matters caused two other jurors dismissals from the jury.
When asked, other jurors indicated that they unanimously selected Sonja Chambers as their foreperson because she carried herself professionally and was a fair person. This raises obvious questions about the other jurors, including, 1.) Did they know her before meeting her in the courtroom? 2.) How do they evaluate people on professionalism and fairness? 3.) Were the other jurors qualified to sit on any several-month-long trial jury where understanding, assimilating, analyzing, using integrity and drawing conclusions is critical?
Today anyone could be accused of and charged with misdemeanors and felonies by anyone else for many wildly, but imaginable reasons including envy, revenge, and anger. Those charged would need a fair trial. In today's broken down jury system, any of us might possibly be a victim of injustice. We need a professional jury system. A professional jury system would consist of trustworthy, prepared jurors who had been vetted and would be paid appropriately.
Civilized people in today's complex, litigious culture cannot afford to benignly accept our damaged jury system as being available and fair if we should need it. Our jury system lacks integrity and draws form a polluted pool.
 
GlobalNewscast Home